From smoky Old Fashioneds to bright, citrusy Margaritas, the world of cocktails is endlessly debated among bartenders and home mixologists alike. The perfect cocktail can turn a simple evening into a memorable one, but everyone has their own idea of what belongs at the top of the list. Cast your vote and help settle the ultimate debate on which cocktail truly reigns supreme.
What counts: Seeded with approximate figures where shown — the crowd's votes decide the order.
Old fashioned▲ Rising
Born in 1880s Louisville as bourbon, sugar, bitters, and a twist got whittled down to their essence, it's the cocktail that literally named the category. Its comeback via Mad Men turned it into the bartender's litmus test — order one and watch how they handle the muddle, the ice, the restraint. It sits atop this list because it never needed reinvention, only rediscovery.
added by IJRin 2 rankings
Margarita▲ Rising
Whether it started in a Tijuana bar or a Texas socialite's blender, the tequila-lime-orange liqueur trio became America's best-selling cocktail by sheer, unapologetic drinkability. It survived the slushy-machine, salt-rimmed frat-party era and came out the other side as a serious pour once bartenders swapped mixto for 100% agave. Few drinks span dive bar and tasting menu with equal credibility — that range earns its spot.
added by IJR
Mojito▲ Rising
Hemingway's supposed Havana favorite turned white rum, mint, lime, and soda into a hot-weather ritual, the sound of muddled leaves becoming shorthand for vacation itself. It rode a massive 2000s surge that put mint sprigs on every bar's shopping list and proved a cocktail could be refreshing without being boring. Its crime is inconsistency — a great mojito is transcendent, a bad one is sugar water — but the ceiling is high enough to matter.
added by IJR
Negroni▲ Rising
Legend says Count Camillo Negroni asked a Florentine bartender to strengthen his Americano with gin instead of soda, and the resulting equal-parts gin, Campari, and sweet vermouth became bitter's great ambassador. It's the drink that taught a generation of palates to love Campari's medicinal snap, and its perfect symmetry made it a bartender's darling for riffs and variations. No cocktail has done more to make bitterness fashionable again.
added by IJR
Whiskey sour
Bourbon, lemon, sugar, and a foam of egg white built a drink so foundational that entire cocktail families — the 'sours' — are named after it. Its comeback owes everything to bartenders rediscovering egg white texture as craft rather than gimmick, turning a Prohibition-era staple into a showpiece of technique. It's the drink that proves balance, not novelty, is the hardest trick in the book.
added by IJR
Espresso martini
Dick Bradsell allegedly built it in 1980s London for a model who wanted something to "wake me up and f*** me up," and the vodka-espresso-coffee liqueur shot answered both requests. It became the 2010s nightlife anthem, the drink that got an entire generation ordering cocktails at 1am who'd otherwise have stuck to shots. Divisive among purists, undeniable in sales — it belongs here because relevance is its own kind of greatness.
added by IJR
Paloma▼ Falling
More popular in Mexico than the margarita itself, tequila and grapefruit soda over ice built its reputation on being uncomplicated and endlessly refreshing rather than photogenic. It never had a Hollywood moment or a marketing campaign — it just quietly became the drink actual tequila-drinking countries reach for. Its case for inclusion is authenticity: this is the tequila cocktail without the tourist trap attached.
added by IJR
Manhattan
Whiskey, sweet vermouth, and bitters, stirred and strained into a drink so classically composed it reads like a tuxedo. Its mythical origin story — a party thrown by Jennie Jerome, Churchill's mother, at the Manhattan Club — may be apocryphal, but its status as the Old Fashioned's more urbane cousin isn't. It's the drink that made rye whiskey cool again, proof that a three-ingredient formula can carry a century of reinvention.
added by IJR
Daiquiri▼ Falling
Named for a Cuban mining town, rum, lime, and sugar shaken cold became Hemingway's other obsession — he reportedly downed doubles of the Floridita's version, no sugar, extra rum. Its dive into blender-slushy territory in the mid-20th century nearly buried its reputation, but the classic shaken version remains the industry's gold standard for testing a bartender's technique. Simplicity this exposed leaves nowhere to hide, which is exactly the point.
added by IJR
Moscow mule▼ Falling
A vodka distributor, a ginger beer maker, and a copper mug manufacturer allegedly conspired in 1941 to move unsold inventory — and accidentally created an icon. The copper mug became the drink's real signature, an Instagram prop before Instagram existed, credited with single-handedly making vodka America's spirit of choice in the 1950s. It's marketing genius disguised as a cocktail, and that hustle deserves recognition.
added by IJR
Free account · your comment posts right after signup
Exactly the kind of argument the internet was built for.
This order is closer to right than any editor would've gotten.
Voted — and the gap between #1 and #2 should be bigger.
The crowd is sleeping on the bottom half of this list.