Farming sims blend relaxing crop management, community building, and long-term progression in ways that reward hundreds of hours. The genre exploded after Stardew Valley revived it, but choices range from hyper-realistic machinery to cozy magical villages. Vote to rank the titles that best capture the joy of the harvest.
What counts: Best balances depth of farming systems, replayability, and accessibility; Metacritic and price figures are approximate public averages.
Stardew Valley▲ Rising
Eric Barone’s solo passion project revived the genre by expanding Harvest Moon’s formula into deep relationships, mining, and seasonal strategy. Its 1.0 launch in 2016 and ongoing free updates turned it into the gold standard that every new farming sim is measured against.
Release Year: 2016Metacritic: 89/10Price: $15Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 10/10
added by IJRin 12 rankingsStardew Valley
Story of Seasons: Friends of Mineral Town▲ Rising
The faithful remake of the beloved Game Boy Advance classic brought back the tight village rhythms and satisfying crop cycles that defined the series. It proved the original Harvest Moon formula still holds up when polished.
Release Year: 2020Metacritic: 77/10Price: $20Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 8/10
added by IJRStory of Seasons: Friends of Mineral Town
Farming Simulator 22▲ Rising
GIANTS Software’s realistic series reached new heights with seasonal crops, production chains, and massive machinery. It remains the definitive choice for players who want authentic tractor physics and economic spreadsheets.
Release Year: 2021Metacritic: 76/10Price: $40Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 9/10
added by IJR
Animal Crossing: New Horizons▲ Rising
Nintendo’s island life sim let millions design and terraform their own paradises during lockdown, turning farming and decorating into a global phenomenon. The 2020 release proved cozy simulation could reach mainstream audiences like nothing else.
Release Year: 2020Metacritic: 90/10Price: $60Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJRin 6 rankingsAnimal Crossing: New Horizons
Dinkum▲ Rising
James Bendon’s Australian outback sim captured the spirit of Stardew Valley with local wildlife and procedural towns. Its 2022 early access proved demand for fresh settings beyond generic fantasy farms.
Release Year: 2022Metacritic: —Price: $20Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJRDinkum
Coral Island▲ Rising
The 2023 tropical farming sim brought inclusive representation and ocean conservation into the genre while delivering classic crop and relationship loops. It earned its spot by refreshing the formula with underwater farming.
Release Year: 2023Metacritic: 76/10Price: $30Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 8/10
added by IJRcoral island
Rune Factory 4 Special
The enhanced port of the fan-favorite entry merged farming with dungeon crawling and romance in a way few games attempt. Its 2019 Switch release finally gave Western players the definitive version they had waited years for.
Release Year: 2019Metacritic: 81/10Price: $30Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 8/10
added by IJR
Monomi Park turned ranching into an exploration and automation puzzle by replacing crops with colorful, bouncing slimes. Its 2017 early-access launch created a fresh sub-genre that still feels unique.
Release Year: 2017Metacritic: 81/10Price: $25Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJRSlime Rancher
My Time at Portia▲ Rising
Pathea’s workshop sim combined farming with crafting commissions and town-building, giving players a clear economic role in a growing community. Its 2018 release showed how post-apocalyptic settings could still feel cozy.
Release Year: 2018Metacritic: 73/10Price: $20Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJRMy Time At Portia
Paleo Pines▲ Rising
The dinosaur ranching sim launched in 2023 and combined farming with befriending colorful dinos in a charming prehistoric world. It proved the genre could thrive with a fresh creature-collecting twist.
Release Year: 2023Metacritic: 72/10Price: $30Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJRPaleo Pines
Sun Haven▲ Rising
The fantasy farming sim added magic, multiple races, and co-op to the Stardew template, launching in 2021 and steadily expanding. It carved a niche for players wanting spells alongside scarecrows.
Release Year: 2021Metacritic: —Price: $25Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 8/10
added by IJRSun Haven
Roots of Pacha▼ Falling
The 2023 prehistoric farming sim replaced modern tools with stone-age innovations and community rituals. It stood out by tying farming progress directly to tribal development.
Release Year: 2023Metacritic: 76/10Price: $25Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 8/10
added by IJRRoots of Pacha
Farm Together▲ Rising
The 2018 co-op farming sim focused entirely on building beautiful shared farms without combat or stress. It filled a niche for players who want pure creative farming with friends.
Release Year: 2018Metacritic: 73/10Price: $20Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 6/10
added by IJR
Cattails: Wildwood Story▼ Falling
The 2023 cat-colony farming RPG mixed hunting, territory management, and simple crops in a feline world. It delivered a compact, charming experience for players who want cats instead of humans.
Release Year: 2023Metacritic: 75/10Price: $20Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 6/10
added by IJR
Farm RPG▼ Falling
The text-based farming sim launched in 2022 and delivered deep progression through simple menus and pixel art. It proved farming games can succeed without heavy graphics.
Release Year: 2022Metacritic: —Price: $5Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJR
Supercell’s long-running mobile hit proved farming games could succeed with simple production chains and neighbor trading. Since 2012 it has remained one of the most accessible entries for casual players.
Release Year: 2012Metacritic: —Price: $0Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 6/10
added by IJRHay Day
Staxel▼ Falling
The 2019 voxel-based farming sim combined block-building with crop management and villager quests. It offered a creative middle ground between Minecraft and traditional farming games.
Release Year: 2019Metacritic: 70/10Price: $20Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJR
The 2023 sequel to My Time at Portia moved the workshop formula to a desert town with improved storytelling and deeper relationships. It refined everything fans loved while adding new production lines.
Release Year: 2023Metacritic: 80/10Price: $40Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJRMy Time at Sandrock
Everdream Valley▼ Falling
The 2023 family-friendly sim added magical animal abilities to classic farming loops. It targeted younger players while still offering satisfying progression for adults.
Release Year: 2023Metacritic: 68/10Price: $25Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJREverdream Valley
The 2024 mech-farming sim combined relaxing crop work with exploration on an alien planet. Its early-access debut introduced fresh movement mechanics while keeping the core loop intact.
Release Year: 2024Metacritic: —Price: $25Multiplayer: ✓Farming Depth: 7/10
added by IJRLightyear Frontier
Graveyard Keeper▼ Falling
Lazy Bear Games mixed dark humor with surprisingly deep farming and production chains in a medieval graveyard setting. Its 2018 release showed farming can work even in a macabre world.
Release Year: 2018Metacritic: 71/10Price: $20Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 8/10
added by IJRGraveyard Keeper
The Ranch of Rivershine▼ Falling
The 2023 horse-ranch sim combined farming with competitive riding and animal care. It carved a niche for players who want equestrian life alongside crops.
Release Year: 2023Metacritic: 72/10Price: $25Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 6/10
added by IJR
No Place Like Home▼ Falling
The 2022 eco-focused sim centered on cleaning up a polluted planet through farming and recycling. It offered a positive message alongside satisfying production chains.
Release Year: 2022Metacritic: 70/10Price: $20Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 6/10
added by IJRNo Place Like Home
Pumpkin Days▼ Falling
The 2019 farming sim emphasized seasonal festivals and town events in a pumpkin-themed world. It delivered a compact, event-driven experience for players who enjoy calendar management.
Release Year: 2019Metacritic: —Price: $15Multiplayer: —Farming Depth: 6/10
added by IJR
Free account · your comment posts right after signup
Wild that Stardew Valley is winning this. Scroll down — the real answer is further down the board.
Came for the argument, stayed for the comparison grid. The numbers settle half the fights here.
Stardew Valley at the top is the correct call and I'll die on this hill.
Missing a few names that belong in the top ten, but the top three is basically right.
This is the most honest version of this ranking I've seen anywhere. The pros and cons are fair.
Somebody explain the Stardew Valley votes to me. Genuinely. I want to understand.