a Yourlist ranking · the crowd decides the order
From reigning Super Bowl champs to rising sophomores, which quarterback would you trust with the ball right now? Vote and rank them.
What counts: Ranking blends current on-field performance, postseason pedigree, and trajectory — not just career totals. All stats (passer rating, rings, MVPs) are approximate and rounded for comparison purposes.
.jpg?width=512)
Three rings in five trips, two MVPs, and a habit of manufacturing miracles in the fourth quarter of Super Bowls — Mahomes has turned the Chiefs into the league's defining dynasty. No one combines improvisational chaos with cold-blooded precision quite like him, and until someone
Current Form: 9.8/10Super Bowl Rings: 3MVP Awards: 2Career Passer Rating: 108Seasons Active: 2017-present
added by IJRin 5 rankingsPatrick Mahomes
Josh Allen
The cannon-armed bulldozer who turned Buffalo into perennial AFC East royalty, Allen's 2024 MVP-caliber season finally paired his freak athleticism with genuine efficiency. He's still chasing that elusive Super Bowl, but the tools and the improvement curve are undeniable.
Current Form: 9.5/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 92Seasons Active: 2018-present
added by IJRin 4 rankings
_(cropped).jpg?width=512)
Ice-in-his-veins from day one, Burrow dragged a rebuilding Bengals team to a Super Bowl in year two and has since become one of the league's premier pure passers. Injuries have slowed the ring count, but when healthy, his combination of accuracy and clutch gene rivals anyone acti
Current Form: 9.3/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 98Seasons Active: 2020-present
added by IJRin 3 rankingsJoe Burrow
Lamar Jackson
A two-time unanimous-caliber MVP who reinvented what a quarterback's legs could do to a defense, Lamar silenced doubters about his passing by piling up efficient, dominant regular seasons. The playoff résumé still lags the regular-season brilliance, but few players are more must-
Current Form: 9.4/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 2Career Passer Rating: 99Seasons Active: 2018-present
added by IJRin 3 rankings
.jpg?width=512)
From backup-turned-starter to a Super Bowl appearance and the invention of the unstoppable 'tush push,' Hurts has proven doubters wrong at every turn. His blend of power running and improved passing has made Philly a perennial contender.
Current Form: 9.1/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 97Seasons Active: 2020-present
added by IJRin 2 rankingsJalen Hurts

Blessed with maybe the purest arm talent in the league, Herbert has quietly piled up gaudy passing numbers in Los Angeles despite shaky supporting casts and coaching turnover. The next step is translating regular-season brilliance into deep playoff runs.
Current Form: 8.9/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 98Seasons Active: 2020-present
added by IJRin 2 rankingsJustin Herbert
The steady, record-setting engine of America's Team, Dak has thrown for gaudy yardage totals and signed a franchise-record contract, yet the Cowboys' postseason ceiling remains stubbornly low. Reliable and productive, but the 'is he elite' debate never fully goes away.
Current Form: 8.7/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 97Seasons Active: 2016-present
added by IJRDak Prescott
Cast off by the Rams after a Super Bowl loss, Goff resurrected his career in Detroit, leading the Lions to their first playoff success in decades with career-best accuracy numbers. His redemption arc is one of the league's best recent stories.
Current Form: 8.6/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 96Seasons Active: 2016-present
added by IJRJared Goff
'Mr. Irrelevant' became the last pick of the draft to start a Super Bowl-caliber offense within two seasons, thriving inside Kyle Shanahan's system. Skeptics call him a product of scheme and talent around him, but the winning has been undeniable.
Current Form: 8.8/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 100Seasons Active: 2022-present
added by IJRBrock Purdy
C.J. Stroud
A rookie-of-the-year campaign that included a legendary playoff comeback in the snow announced Stroud as a franchise cornerstone almost immediately. Houston hasn't had a quarterback this promising in a generation.
Current Form: 8.7/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 100Seasons Active: 2023-present
added by IJRin 2 rankings
When healthy, Tua's rhythm-and-timing precision has produced some of the most efficient passing seasons in Dolphins history, but recurring injuries have made durability the central question of his career. The talent is real; the availability is the debate.
Current Form: 8.2/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 98Seasons Active: 2020-present
added by IJRTua Tagovailoa
Trevor Lawrence
Once the most hyped quarterback prospect in a decade, Lawrence has had a bumpy start in Jacksonville with inconsistent surrounding talent and coaching change. The tools remain elite; the results are still catching up.
Current Form: 7.8/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 88Seasons Active: 2021-present
added by IJR
A dazzling dual-threat talent who's flashed MVP-level ceiling in bursts, Murray's Arizona tenure has been defined by inconsistency, injuries, and swirling trade rumors rather than sustained dominance.
Current Form: 7.9/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 92Seasons Active: 2019-present
added by IJRKyler Murray
Matthew Stafford
After a decade of gunslinging futility in Detroit, Stafford finally got his ring in his first year with the Rams, silencing years of 'wasted talent' narratives. Now in his late thirties, he's still slinging it at a high level in Los Angeles.
Current Form: 8/10Super Bowl Rings: 1MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 90Seasons Active: 2009-present
added by IJR
Written off after a rocky Cleveland exit and journeyman stint, Mayfield resurrected his career in Tampa Bay with a career-best statistical season and renewed swagger. The comeback story is one of the league's most satisfying recent turnarounds.
Current Form: 7.9/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 88Seasons Active: 2018-present
added by IJRBaker Mayfield
Jordan Love
Handed the keys after years behind Aaron Rodgers, Love answered doubts with a breakout campaign that included a playoff win over Dallas, proving Green Bay's succession plan can work. Still early, but the arm talent and poise are evident.
Current Form: 8.1/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 92Seasons Active: 2020-present
added by IJR
A remarkable late-career renaissance took Smith from journeyman backup to Pro Bowl starter and Comeback Player of the Year in Seattle, proving persistence can pay off. He's become a steady, efficient presence long after most had written him off.
Current Form: 7.6/10Super Bowl Rings: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passer Rating: 92Seasons Active: 2013-present
added by IJRGeno Smith
.jpg?width=512)
A four-time MVP and one-time champion whose prime featured some of the most jaw-dropping improvisational football ever played, Rodgers is now fighting time and injury in New York trying to add one more chapter. The legacy is cemented; the current form is the question mark.
Current Form: 7/10Super Bowl Rings: 1MVP Awards: 4Career Passer Rating: 100Seasons Active: 2005-present
added by IJRin 3 rankingsAaron Rodgers
Free account · your comment posts right after signup