The Nintendo DS launched a golden era of portable innovation with touch screens, dual screens, and Wi-Fi play that reshaped handheld gaming. Decades later, fans still debate which titles best captured that hardware magic and delivered timeless experiences. Vote to rank them.
What counts: Best means highest replay value, hardware innovation, and lasting cultural impact on the DS; all figures are approximate Metacritic scores and sales estimates.
Mario Kart DS▲ Rising
Mario Kart DS proved online racing could thrive on handhelds and turned every bus ride into a tournament. Its 32-player Wi-Fi mode and tight tracks made it the system seller that still feels current.
Year: 2005Genre: RacingMetacritic: 91/10Sales: 23.6 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRMario Kart DS
Professor Layton and the Curious Village▲ Rising
Professor Layton turned puzzle collections into a charming mystery series and proved the DS could deliver narrative-driven experiences. Its brain-teasers and Victorian style became a franchise staple.
Year: 2007Genre: PuzzleMetacritic: 85/10Sales: 3.8 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRin 2 rankingsProfessor Layton and the Curious Village
New Super Mario Bros.▲ Rising
New Super Mario Bros. revived 2D Mario with modern level design and touch-based power-ups that felt fresh on the dual screens. It became the blueprint for every later New Super Mario release.
Year: 2006Genre: PlatformerMetacritic: 89/10Sales: 30.8 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRin 3 rankingsNew Super Mario Bros.
Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver▲ Rising
HeartGold and SoulSilver updated the Johto classics with the Pokéwalker accessory and improved visuals that honored the originals while expanding them. They remain the gold standard for Pokémon remakes.
Year: 2009Genre: RPGMetacritic: 87/10Sales: 12.7 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRin 2 rankingsPokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver
The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass▲ Rising
Phantom Hourglass brought the Wind Waker formula to the DS stylus and proved touch controls could feel natural for adventure games. Its temple puzzles and sea exploration defined early DS ambition.
Year: 2007Genre: Action-AdventureMetacritic: 90/10Sales: 4.8 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRThe Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass
Chrono Trigger▲ Rising
The DS port of Chrono Trigger added new dungeons and an animated ending that finally gave fans the definitive version they wanted. Its time-travel story and combat still hold up as peak JRPG design.
Year: 2008Genre: RPGMetacritic: 92/10Sales: 0.9 MDS Exclusive: —
added by IJRin 10 rankingsChrono Trigger
The World Ends with You▲ Rising
The World Ends with You used both screens and the stylus for a combat system that perfectly matched its Shibuya teen-reaper story. Its stylish presentation and deep mechanics made it an instant cult classic.
Year: 2007Genre: Action RPGMetacritic: 88/10Sales: 0.6 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRin 3 rankingsThe World Ends with You
Super Mario 64 DS added new characters and levels while proving the DS could handle 3D Mario. Its touch-screen map and mini-games made the classic feel fresh again.
Year: 2004Genre: PlatformerMetacritic: 87/10Sales: 11.1 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRSuper Mario 64 DS
Metroid Prime Hunters▲ Rising
Metroid Prime Hunters brought first-person exploration and multiplayer deathmatches to the DS with impressive technical ambition. Its bounty-hunter cast and scan visor fit the series perfectly.
Year: 2006Genre: FPSMetacritic: 85/10Sales: 1 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRMetroid Prime Hunters
Wild World brought the relaxing life sim to portable play and turned the DS into a daily social hub for millions of players. Its real-time clock and friend visits created lasting personal memories.
Year: 2005Genre: Life SimMetacritic: 86/10Sales: 11.8 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRAnimal Crossing: Wild World
Platinum expanded the Sinnoh region with the Distortion World and improved online features that made it the definitive fourth-gen Pokémon experience.
Year: 2008Genre: RPGMetacritic: 84/10Sales: 7.1 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRin 2 rankingsPokémon Platinum
Elite Beat Agents▲ Rising
Elite Beat Agents turned rhythm gameplay into an over-the-top cheerleading spectacle that used the stylus in inventive ways. Its energetic covers and level variety made it one of the DS's most joyful surprises.
Year: 2006Genre: RhythmMetacritic: 87/10Sales: 1 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRElite Beat Agents
Dawn of Sorrow refined the Sorrow formula with soul collection and castle exploration that felt bigger than the GBA entries. Its dark atmosphere and weapon variety made it a 2D Metroidvania highlight.
Year: 2005Genre: ActionMetacritic: 85/10Sales: 0.5 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRCastlevania: Dawn of Sorrow
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney▲ Rising
Phoenix Wright brought visual-novel courtroom drama to the DS and made objection gameplay iconic. Its clever cases and memorable characters launched a long-running franchise.
Year: 2005Genre: AdventureMetacritic: 81/10Sales: 0.5 MDS Exclusive: —
added by IJRin 2 rankingsPhoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
Dragon Quest IX: Sentinels of the Starry Skies▼ Falling
Dragon Quest IX brought full multiplayer co-op to the series and let players create their own heroes for the first time. Its massive post-game and customization kept fans busy for years.
Year: 2009Genre: RPGMetacritic: 87/10Sales: 4.9 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJR
Shadow Dragon brought the first Fire Emblem to Western audiences with updated visuals and the classic permadeath tension. Its story and unit management made it essential for strategy fans.
Year: 2008Genre: Strategy RPGMetacritic: 82/10Sales: 0.4 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRFire Emblem: Shadow Dragon
Canvas Curse turned Kirby into a stylus-controlled ball and created inventive levels around that new mechanic. Its creative puzzles and charming art made it a DS standout.
Year: 2005Genre: PlatformerMetacritic: 86/10Sales: 0.3 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRKirby: Canvas Curse
Brain Age: Train Your Brain in Minutes a Day▼ Falling
Brain Age popularized quick daily mental exercises on the DS and convinced parents the system had educational value. Its simple tests and progress tracking made it a phenomenon.
Year: 2005Genre: EdutainmentMetacritic: 75/10Sales: 19 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJR
Final Fantasy IV▼ Falling
The DS remake of Final Fantasy IV added voice acting and updated graphics that finally brought the classic to a new generation with modern polish. Its epic story and job system remained compelling.
Year: 2007Genre: RPGMetacritic: 85/10Sales: 0.7 MDS Exclusive: —
added by IJRin 2 rankingsFinal Fantasy IV
Sonic Rush▼ Falling
Sonic Rush brought blazing 2D speed back to Sonic with a dual-screen gimmick and tight platforming that recaptured the series' spark. Its level design and boss fights stood out.
Year: 2005Genre: PlatformerMetacritic: 82/10Sales: 1 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRin 2 rankingsSonic Rush
Dual Strike brought deep turn-based tactics to the DS with dual-screen maps and CO powers that rewarded smart play. Its campaign and versus modes kept strategy fans hooked.
Year: 2005Genre: StrategyMetacritic: 85/10Sales: 0.4 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRAdvance Wars: Dual Strike
Nintendogs▼ Falling
Nintendogs turned pet simulation into a touch-screen sensation that sold millions and showed the DS could reach non-gamers. Its simple care mechanics and voice recognition created instant attachment.
Year: 2005Genre: Pet SimMetacritic: 83/10Sales: 23.6 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRNintendogs
Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time▼ Falling
Partners in Time expanded the Mario & Luigi formula with time travel and baby versions of the brothers for fresh puzzle-solving. Its humor and battle system kept the RPG series strong.
Year: 2005Genre: RPGMetacritic: 83/10Sales: 1.3 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJRMario & Luigi: Partners in Time
Diddy Kong Racing DS▼ Falling
Diddy Kong Racing DS updated the N64 classic with touch-screen controls and new tracks that tried to modernize the kart racer. Its adventure mode and character roster still hold nostalgic appeal.
Year: 2007Genre: RacingMetacritic: 68/10Sales: 0.8 MDS Exclusive: ✓
added by IJR
Free account · your comment posts right after signup
Missing a few names that belong in the top ten, but the top three is basically right.
This is the most honest version of this ranking I've seen anywhere. The pros and cons are fair.
Came for the argument, stayed for the comparison grid. The numbers settle half the fights here.
Wild that Mario Kart DS is winning this. Scroll down — the real answer is further down the board.
Mario Kart DS at the top is the correct call and I'll die on this hill.
The criteria line matters here. Read it before you vote or you're arguing about a different list.