Best Pet Insurance Companies

Trupanion

Trupanion built its reputation on the direct vet-pay flourish — software installed right at checkout counters so a $6,000 ACL surgery bill gets slashed to a copay before you even leave the clinic. That single feature turned it into the go-to for owners of accident-prone breeds who dread fronting cash, even though the flat 90% reimbursement (after a per-condition deductible) comes at a premium that climbs steeply as pets age. It's the plan vets themselves often recommend, which says something about its claims credibility.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $65Customer Rating: 8/10Typical Waiting Period: 5 days accident / 30 days illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2000

added by IJRTrupanion

Healthy Paws

Healthy Paws made its name with unlimited payouts and a claims process so fast that owners have posted screenshots of reimbursements landing within two days of a cancer diagnosis. The catch that keeps it from the very top is its hard line on hip dysplasia coverage and a lack of wellness add-ons, but for catastrophic illness protection with no lifetime caps, it's hard to beat. Its cult following among dog owners who've weathered a $15,000 surgery is the loudest endorsement in the industry.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $45Customer Rating: 8.5/10Typical Waiting Period: 15 days illness / no accident waitCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2009

added by IJR

Nationwide

Nationwide is the only major insurer to cover birds, reptiles, and exotic pets, a niche it's owned since absorbing the old VPI brand decades ago — making it the default answer whenever someone asks 'can I insure my parrot?' Its whole-pet-with-wellness plan is beloved by multi-species households, though claim payouts run on a benefit schedule that can shortchange owners expecting straight percentage reimbursement. It earns its spot as the legacy generalist that quietly insures more unusual pets than anyone else.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $50Customer Rating: 7.5/10Typical Waiting Period: 14 days accident/illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: —Founded: 1982

added by IJRNationwide

ASPCA Pet Health Insurance

Riding the trusted ASPCA name (though actually underwritten by Crum & Forster), this plan won over budget-conscious owners with one of the lowest entry price points in the category, often under $30/month for young dogs. The brand halo does a lot of heavy lifting, and coverage customization is solid, but claims-processing speed has drawn more complaints than its charitable namesake would like. It lands mid-pack: a fine value pick, not a class leader.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $40Customer Rating: 7.3/10Typical Waiting Period: 14 days accident/illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2006

added by IJR

Embrace

Embrace's signature move is the diminishing deductible — knock $50 off your deductible every claim-free year, a small mechanic that rewards loyalty in a way almost no competitor bothers to. Its wellness rider and 24/7 vet chatline make it a favorite for first-time pet parents navigating claims for the first time, and customer service reviews consistently praise the human warmth behind the phone line. It's the insurer that turned an actuarial detail into genuine brand affection.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $40Customer Rating: 8.2/10Typical Waiting Period: 2 days accident / 14 days illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2003

added by IJR

Pets Best

Founded by a veterinarian who also helped launch VPI, Pets Best built its reputation on fast, vet-savvy claims handling and one of the few unlimited-annual-limit plans priced competitively for older dogs. Its routine-care add-on is genuinely useful rather than a marketing gimmick, covering things like dental cleanings that many rivals bury in fine print. It's the dependable, unglamorous workhorse of the category — never flashy, rarely disappointing.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $40Customer Rating: 7.8/10Typical Waiting Period: 3 days accident / 14 days illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2005

added by IJR

Prudent Pet

Prudent Pet elbowed into the market with an unusual unlimited-everything top tier plan and a 24/7 vet telehealth line bundled in even at lower tiers, chasing Lemonade's tech-forward customers without Lemonade's app-only impersonality. It's still building a claims-payout track record long enough to earn full trust, but early reviews suggest genuinely fast turnaround. A newer name worth watching rather than a proven institution.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $40Customer Rating: 6.9/10Typical Waiting Period: 5 days accident / 14 days illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2019

added by IJR

Fetch by The Dodo

Fetch (formerly Petplan) leaned into its media parentage, marketing itself through The Dodo's viral animal videos while quietly offering one of the highest coverage ceilings in the industry, including exam fees and behavioral therapy many competitors exclude. Its willingness to cover things like boarding fees if you're hospitalized made it a sleeper favorite among owners with anxious or complex-needs pets. The catch is premiums that climb noticeably with age, tempering the enthusiasm.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $45Customer Rating: 8/10Typical Waiting Period: 15 days accident/illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2003

added by IJR

AKC Pet Insurance

Leaning hard on the American Kennel Club's credibility, this insurer (underwritten by PetPartners) targets purebred owners with breed-specific hereditary condition coverage that generic plans often exclude outright. It's a smart, targeted pitch — if you own a bulldog worried about brachycephalic issues, this is the plan built with you in mind — but its customer service reputation is thinner and more mixed than the AKC name might suggest. Niche appeal, solid but unspectacular execution.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $45Customer Rating: 6.7/10Typical Waiting Period: 14 days accident/illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2003

added by IJR

Lemonade Pet Insurance

Lemonade brought its Giveback-donation gimmick and AI-claims-bot from renters insurance straight into pet coverage, famously paying out simple claims in minutes through its app rather than weeks by mail. Bundling pet insurance with home or renters policies for a discount won over young, tech-native owners, though its limited state availability and newer track record leave longtime pet owners a little wary of untested claims history during a real crisis. It's the disruptor everyone's watching, not yet the safest bet.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $35Customer Rating: 7.6/10Typical Waiting Period: 2 days accident / 14 days illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2020

added by IJR

Figo Pet Insurance

Figo's claim to fame is its slick app featuring a 'Pet Cloud' social network and a 100% reimbursement tier that undercuts even Trupanion on paper, appealing to owners who want maximalist coverage and don't mind maximalist premiums. It processes claims faster than most legacy insurers, a genuine strength, but its unlimited-everything plan pricing scales aggressively once a dog crosses into senior years. Best for tech-comfortable owners chasing top-dollar reimbursement.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $45Customer Rating: 7.4/10Typical Waiting Period: 1 day accident / 14 days illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2012

added by IJR

MetLife Pet Insurance

MetLife leveraged its insurance-giant infrastructure to offer multi-pet and employer-benefit discounts that few boutique pet insurers can match, becoming the quiet default option when pet coverage shows up as a workplace perk. It lacks a splashy signature moment — no viral claims story, no gimmick — which is exactly its pitch: institutional stability over flash. Reliable, if a little forgettable next to louder competitors.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $45Customer Rating: 7.2/10Typical Waiting Period: 14 days accident/illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2019

added by IJR

Spot Pet Insurance

Spot carved a niche by insuring pets as young as 8 weeks and as old as 15 years with no upper age cutoff for enrollment, a real lifeline for owners of senior rescues that other insurers simply won't touch. Its unlimited annual limits across every plan tier are a genuine value differentiator, though its shorter operating history means the payout reputation is still being written. A rare insurer that treats old dogs as insurable, not liabilities.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $40Customer Rating: 7/10Typical Waiting Period: 14 days accident/illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2019

added by IJR

Progressive Pet Insurance

Progressive doesn't underwrite its own pet policies — it white-labels through Pets Best — but its real value is the multi-policy discount stacking with auto and home insurance that turns pet coverage into a rounding-error add-on for existing customers. It's less a distinct product than a convenient bundle, which is precisely why loyal Progressive customers add it without ever shopping around. Convenience over distinction.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $40Customer Rating: 6.8/10Typical Waiting Period: 3 days accident / 14 days illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2019

added by IJR

Pumpkin Pet Insurance

Pumpkin made waves with its 'Preventive Essentials' package that reimburses 100% of wellness costs like vaccines and dental cleanings outright rather than as a capped add-on, a structure that resonated instantly with millennial pet owners treating pets like family. Backed by the same underwriter as several rivals, it differentiates almost entirely on branding and app polish rather than claims mechanics, but that branding has genuinely moved the market toward friendlier, plainer-language policies. Style with real substance.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $45Customer Rating: 7.5/10Typical Waiting Period: 14 days accident/illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2020

added by IJR

CarePlus by Chewy

CarePlus rode Chewy's existing trust and massive customer base to a fast launch, letting pet owners buy insurance in the same checkout flow as dog food — a frictionless entry point no competitor can replicate. It's underwritten by Lemonade, inheriting the app-based claims speed, but its true asset is Chewy's 24/7 customer service reputation bleeding over into the insurance product. Convenience is the whole pitch, and for many it's compelling enough.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $40Customer Rating: 6.5/10Typical Waiting Period: 14 days accident/illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2022

added by IJR

USAA Pet Insurance

USAA doesn't underwrite its own plan — it partners with Embrace — but for military families already loyal to USAA's legendary customer service, the referral discount and familiar interface make signing up a no-brainer extension of an existing relationship. It's not a distinct product worth chasing on its own merits, and non-military members can't even access it, capping its relevance. A convenience play for a specific, devoted audience rather than a genuine category contender.'

Approx. Monthly Cost: $40Customer Rating: 7.7/10Typical Waiting Period: 2 days accident / 14 days illnessCovers Hereditary/Congenital: ✓Founded: 2020

added by IJR