a Yourlist ranking · the crowd decides the order
From Ruth's called shots to Bonds' record-shattering 73, these sluggers redefined power hitting. Vote for who you think truly deserves the title of the game's greatest home run hitter.
What counts: Ranked by a blend of career home run total, peak-season dominance, and lasting cultural impact on the sport; all statistics are widely reported career figures treated as approximate, and 'legacy' reflects a subjective sense of how much each player shaped the home run's mythology.
Babe Ruth
The Sultan of Swat didn't just hit home runs, he invented the modern power game, hitting 60 in 1927 when the next-best team barely matched him. His shadow still looms over every slugger who's ever stepped in the box.
Career Home Runs: 714 HRBest Single Season: 60 HRYears Active: 1914-1935Career Batting Avg: 0.342Legacy: 10/10
added by IJRin 7 rankings

Aaron chased down Ruth's untouchable record amid death threats and racist hate mail, finishing with 755 through sheer relentless consistency rather than one explosive peak season. His dignity under pressure makes his crown as meaningful as the number itself.
Career Home Runs: 755 HRBest Single Season: 47 HRYears Active: 1954-1976Career Batting Avg: 0.305Legacy: 10/10
added by IJRin 4 rankingsHank Aaron

Bonds holds the all-time record at 762 and the single-season mark of 73, a run so absurd that pitchers simply stopped throwing him strikes. The steroid cloud complicates the story, but the raw numbers remain the mountain everyone else measures against.
Career Home Runs: 762 HRBest Single Season: 73 HRYears Active: 1986-2007Career Batting Avg: 0.298Legacy: 9.5/10
added by IJRin 6 rankingsBarry Bonds

Pujols spent two decades as the most feared right-handed bat in baseball, capping his career by chasing and passing 700 home runs in his final season with the Cardinals. His blend of power and average places him among the most complete hitters ever.
Career Home Runs: 703 HRBest Single Season: 49 HRYears Active: 2001-2022Career Batting Avg: 0.296Legacy: 9/10
added by IJRin 5 rankingsAlbert Pujols
Alex Rodriguez
A-Rod combined shortstop athleticism with elite power, becoming the youngest player to 500 homers before PED admissions tarnished his legacy. Still, 696 career homers and multiple MVPs keep him firmly in the conversation.
Career Home Runs: 696 HRBest Single Season: 57 HRYears Active: 1994-2016Career Batting Avg: 0.295Legacy: 8.5/10
added by IJRin 2 rankings

The Say Hey Kid hit 660 homers while also being arguably the greatest all-around player ever, robbing home runs in center field as often as he hit them. His power was never the whole story, which is exactly why it's so remarkable.
Career Home Runs: 660 HRBest Single Season: 52 HRYears Active: 1951-1973Career Batting Avg: 0.301Legacy: 9.5/10
added by IJRin 4 rankingsWillie Mays
.jpg?width=512)
Junior made power hitting look effortless with his sweet left-handed swing, launching 56 in back-to-back seasons before injuries slowed him. He's the beloved counterpoint to the steroid era, a 630-homer slugger nobody doubts.
Career Home Runs: 630 HRBest Single Season: 56 HRYears Active: 1989-2010Career Batting Avg: 0.284Legacy: 9/10
added by IJRin 5 rankingsKen Griffey Jr.
Thome quietly climbed to 612 homers with a slow, methodical career built on patience and one of the most feared swings of his generation. He never chased a single-season record, just kept mashing for over two decades.
Career Home Runs: 612 HRBest Single Season: 52 HRYears Active: 1991-2012Career Batting Avg: 0.276Legacy: 7.5/10
added by IJRJim Thome

Sosa's 66-homer chase with McGwire in 1998 electrified a sport still recovering from a strike, making him a national hero before later scandal reframed the story. His 609 career homers still represent one of the most thrilling power surges ever witnessed.
Career Home Runs: 609 HRBest Single Season: 66 HRYears Active: 1989-2007Career Batting Avg: 0.273Legacy: 7/10
added by IJRin 2 rankingsSammy Sosa
Frank Robinson
Robinson won MVP in both leagues and hit 586 homers with a ferocious, no-nonsense approach that intimidated pitchers for two decades. He later became MLB's first Black manager, adding historic weight to an already Hall-worthy playing career.
Career Home Runs: 586 HRBest Single Season: 49 HRYears Active: 1956-1976Career Batting Avg: 0.294Legacy: 8.5/10
added by IJR

Big Mac's 70-homer season in 1998 shattered Roger Maris's record and captivated the country, even as later admissions of steroid use recast the achievement. His raw power remains unmatched for sheer single-season spectacle.
Career Home Runs: 583 HRBest Single Season: 70 HRYears Active: 1986-2001Career Batting Avg: 0.263Legacy: 7/10
added by IJRin 2 rankingsMark McGwire
Killebrew was the original 'Killer' of American League pitching, leading the league in home runs six times with a stocky, unassuming frame that hid tremendous power. His 573 homers made him Minnesota's first true baseball icon.
Career Home Runs: 573 HRBest Single Season: 49 HRYears Active: 1954-1975Career Batting Avg: 0.256Legacy: 7.5/10
added by IJRHarmon Killebrew
Palmeiro joined the elite 500-500 club of homers and doubles, only to have his legacy collapse after a positive steroid test just months after wagging his finger before Congress. His 569 homers remain statistically dominant but permanently asterisked.
Career Home Runs: 569 HRBest Single Season: 47 HRYears Active: 1986-2005Career Batting Avg: 0.288Legacy: 6/10
added by IJRRafael Palmeiro
Reggie Jackson
Mr. October earned his nickname with clutch postseason blasts, including three home runs on three consecutive pitches in Game 6 of the 1977 World Series. His 563 career homers came wrapped in swagger and flair for the biggest moments.
Career Home Runs: 563 HRBest Single Season: 47 HRYears Active: 1967-1987Career Batting Avg: 0.262Legacy: 8/10
added by IJRin 2 rankings
Manny Ramirez
Ramirez paired 555 homers with one of the sweetest right-handed swings ever, hitting for both power and average in a way few sluggers manage. His eccentric personality and PED suspensions add complexity to an otherwise dominant offensive résumé.
Career Home Runs: 555 HRBest Single Season: 45 HRYears Active: 1993-2011Career Batting Avg: 0.312Legacy: 7.5/10
added by IJR
Mike Schmidt
Widely regarded as the greatest third baseman ever, Schmidt combined 548 home runs with elite defense, something almost no other slugger on this list can claim. His all-around excellence made him a three-time MVP in Philadelphia.
Career Home Runs: 548 HRBest Single Season: 48 HRYears Active: 1972-1989Career Batting Avg: 0.267Legacy: 8.5/10
added by IJR
David Ortiz
Big Papi turned clutch October home runs into a personal brand, breaking Boston's 86-year championship curse with legendary postseason power. His 541 homers came almost entirely as a designated hitter, redefining what that role could mean.
Career Home Runs: 541 HRBest Single Season: 54 HRYears Active: 1997-2016Career Batting Avg: 0.286Legacy: 8/10
added by IJRin 2 rankings

Mantle's tape-measure home runs and switch-hitting power made him the face of the Yankees dynasty, even as injuries throughout his career suggest his true ceiling was even higher. His 536 homers came with a mythic, almost tragic aura of unfulfilled potential.
Career Home Runs: 536 HRBest Single Season: 54 HRYears Active: 1951-1968Career Batting Avg: 0.298Legacy: 9/10
added by IJRin 4 rankingsMickey Mantle
Free account · your comment posts right after signup