Greatest Sandwiches of All Time

BLT

Bacon, lettuce, tomato — the holy trinity that proves you don't need fancy ingredients to make perfection. It became a diner and lunch-counter staple across America by the mid-20th century and remains the benchmark for simple sandwich harmony. Its balance of salty, crisp, and jui

Approx. Origin: Late 1800sCraveability: 9/10Typical Price: $8Calories (approx.): 450 kcal

added by IJRin 3 rankingsBLT

Philly Cheesesteak

Born on the streets of South Philadelphia in the 1930s from Pat Olivieri's grilled beef, this sandwich sparked a decades-long rivalry between Pat's and Geno's that still draws tourists today. Melted cheese, thin-sliced ribeye, and a soft roll turned a hot dog cart hustle into a n

Approx. Origin: 1930sCraveability: 9/10Typical Price: $12Calories (approx.): 900 kcal

added by IJRin 2 rankings

Reuben

Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, and Russian dressing grilled between rye bread — a deli masterpiece whose true origin is disputed between Omaha and New York. Its tangy, salty, melty chaos makes it the king of the grilled deli sandwich category. Few sandwiches inspire as much devo

Approx. Origin: 1920sCraveability: 8.7/10Typical Price: $14Calories (approx.): 800 kcal

added by IJRin 2 rankings

Grilled Cheese

The ultimate comfort food, grilled cheese has evolved from Depression-era survival food into a gourmet obsession with truffle and brie variations. Its universal appeal to kids and adults alike, plus its simplicity, cements its place as a sandwich icon. Nothing beats that first cr

Approx. Origin: 1920sCraveability: 8.5/10Typical Price: $6Calories (approx.): 400 kcal

added by IJRin 3 rankingsgrilled cheese

Cubano

A Tampa-versus-Miami origin battle rages over this pressed masterpiece of ham, roast pork, Swiss, pickles, and mustard. Its crispy pressed exterior and layered savory-tangy interior make it one of the most argued-over sandwiches in America. It's the sandwich that turned a diaspor

Approx. Origin: Early 1900sCraveability: 8.6/10Typical Price: $11Calories (approx.): 700 kcal

added by IJR

Banh Mi

A product of French colonial baguettes meeting Vietnamese pickled vegetables, cilantro, and grilled meats, the banh mi is a masterclass in contrast and balance. It exploded in popularity globally in the 2000s as a symbol of fusion cuisine done right. Its crunchy baguette and brig

Approx. Origin: 1950sCraveability: 8.8/10Typical Price: $7Calories (approx.): 500 kcal

added by IJRin 2 rankings

Po' Boy

Born during a 1929 New Orleans streetcar strike, when the Martin brothers fed out-of-work 'poor boys' for free, this overstuffed roast beef or fried seafood sandwich became a Louisiana institution. Its crusty French bread and gravy-soaked drama make it unmistakably New Orleans. N

Approx. Origin: 1929Craveability: 8.5/10Typical Price: $13Calories (approx.): 850 kcal

added by IJR

Italian Sub (Hoagie)

Stacked with cured meats, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and a vinegar-oil dressing, the Italian sub is the deli counter's answer to a full meal in bread form. Philadelphia claims the 'hoagie' name, but every East Coast city has its own legend about its birth. It's the sandwich that

Approx. Origin: Early 1900sCraveability: 8.4/10Typical Price: $10Calories (approx.): 750 kcal

added by IJR

Pastrami on Rye

The crown jewel of Jewish deli culture, piled sky-high at places like Katz's in New York, pastrami on rye is peppery, smoky, and unapologetically excessive. Its mustard-and-rye simplicity lets the hand-cut, slow-cured beef do all the talking. It's the sandwich that defined an ent

Approx. Origin: Late 1800sCraveability: 8.9/10Typical Price: $16Calories (approx.): 700 kcal

added by IJRpastrami on rye

Peanut Butter and Jelly

A lunchbox staple since peanut butter became affordable in the early 1900s, the PB&J is the training-wheels sandwich that most Americans grow up on. Its sweet-salty simplicity and nostalgic pull make it a permanent fixture on any greatest-sandwiches debate, even if it's an underd

Approx. Origin: Early 1900sCraveability: 7.5/10Typical Price: $3Calories (approx.): 350 kcal

added by IJR

French Dip

Los Angeles's Philippe's and Cole's both claim to have invented this thinly sliced beef sandwich served with a side of au jus for dipping, sometime around 1918. Its interactive, messy nature and rich beefy flavor make it a West Coast classic that rivals any East Coast deli sandwi

Approx. Origin: 1918Craveability: 8.2/10Typical Price: $13Calories (approx.): 650 kcal

added by IJRin 2 rankings

Monte Cristo

A French-toast-battered ham and cheese sandwich, often deep-fried and dusted with powdered sugar, the Monte Cristo is dessert and lunch colliding in the best possible way. It gained fame in American diners in the mid-20th century, especially California coffee shops. Its sweet-sav

Approx. Origin: 1950sCraveability: 8/10Typical Price: $12Calories (approx.): 900 kcal

added by IJR

Club Sandwich

Allegedly invented at a Saratoga Springs gentleman's club in the 1890s, the triple-decker turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato club became hotel-menu royalty worldwide. Its toothpick-skewered elegance made it the sandwich of choice for room service everywhere. It's the sandwich tha

Approx. Origin: 1890sCraveability: 8/10Typical Price: $11Calories (approx.): 600 kcal

added by IJRin 3 rankings

Meatball Sub

Italian-American immigrants adapted meatballs into a hearty sandwich smothered in marinara and melted cheese, becoming a red-sauce-joint and pizzeria staple. Its messy, saucy indulgence has made it a lunch-counter and school-cafeteria legend alike. Few sandwiches deliver comfort

Approx. Origin: Early 1900sCraveability: 8.1/10Typical Price: $10Calories (approx.): 800 kcal

added by IJR

Croque Monsieur

France's answer to grilled cheese, the croque monsieur layers ham and Gruyère between béchamel-coated bread, often topped with an egg to become a croque madame. It's a café staple across Paris and a symbol of French bistro comfort food. Its rich, cheesy decadence earns it a spot

Approx. Origin: 1910Craveability: 8.3/10Typical Price: $10Calories (approx.): 550 kcal

added by IJR

Lobster Roll

New England's seaside treasure, the lobster roll pairs chilled or buttered lobster meat with a toasted split-top bun, sparking eternal debate between Maine (cold, mayo) and Connecticut (warm, butter) styles. Its luxurious simplicity and coastal-summer nostalgia make it one of the

Approx. Origin: 1920sCraveability: 8.6/10Typical Price: $22Calories (approx.): 450 kcal

added by IJRlobster roll

Egg Salad Sandwich

A soft, unpretentious deli and tea-room classic, egg salad on white or wheat bread has quietly fed generations without much fanfare. It's the underappreciated workhorse of lunch counters, brunches, and picnics everywhere. Its creamy simplicity earns it a loyal, if quieter, fanbas

Approx. Origin: Early 1900sCraveability: 6.8/10Typical Price: $6Calories (approx.): 350 kcal

added by IJRin 2 rankings

Tuna Salad Sandwich

A pantry-staple classic built on canned tuna, mayo, and celery, this sandwich became a mid-century American lunchbox and diner fixture. It's inexpensive, protein-packed, and endlessly customizable, which has kept it in constant rotation for decades. Its everyman appeal keeps it f

Approx. Origin: 1900sCraveability: 7/10Typical Price: $7Calories (approx.): 400 kcal

added by IJRin 2 rankings