Greatest Senate Showdowns in History

The Great Debate / Compromise of 1850

Henry Clay, Daniel Webster, and John C. Calhoun turned the Senate floor into a three-way wrestling match over slavery's expansion, with Calhoun's speech read aloud by a colleague as he lay dying. Webster's 'Seventh of March' address, defending compromise over disunion, cost him a

Year(s): 1850Drama Level: 9.5/10Historical Impact: 10/10Final Vote/Outcome: Passed as separate bills, no single tallyFilibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Henry Clay, Daniel Webster, John C. Calhoun

added by IJR

The Webster-Hayne Debate

What began as a dry argument over public land policy exploded into a two-week clash over states' rights versus federal union, climaxing in Webster's thunderous 'Liberty and Union, now and forever' peroration. Robert Hayne of South Carolina never quite recovered rhetorically, and

Year(s): 1830Drama Level: 9/10Historical Impact: 8.5/10Final Vote/Outcome: —Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Daniel Webster, Robert Hayne

added by IJR

The Caning of Charles Sumner

Preston Brooks, a House member from South Carolina, strode onto the Senate floor and beat abolitionist Senator Charles Sumner nearly to death with a cane over an anti-slavery speech, leaving Sumner unable to fully serve for years. The North and South reacted in starkly opposite w

Year(s): 1856Drama Level: 9.5/10Historical Impact: 8/10Final Vote/Outcome: —Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Charles Sumner, Preston Brooks

added by IJR

The Treaty of Versailles Rejection

Woodrow Wilson toured the country pleading for the League of Nations while Senator Henry Cabot Lodge methodically built a coalition of 'Reservationists' and 'Irreconcilables' to strangle the treaty. Wilson's refusal to compromise, even after a debilitating stroke, doomed American

Year(s): 1919-1920Drama Level: 9/10Historical Impact: 9.5/10Final Vote/Outcome: 49-35 (fell short of two-thirds)Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Woodrow Wilson, Henry Cabot Lodge

added by IJR

The Andrew Johnson Impeachment Trial

After Johnson defied the Tenure of Office Act, the Senate came within a single vote of removing a sitting president for the first time, with Senator Edmund Ross casting the deciding 'not guilty' vote against enormous pressure from his own party. Ross's vote likely ended his polit

Year(s): 1868Drama Level: 9.5/10Historical Impact: 9/10Final Vote/Outcome: 35-19 (one vote short of conviction)Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Andrew Johnson, Edmund Ross

added by IJR

Strom Thurmond's Record Filibuster

Determined to kill the Civil Rights Act of 1957, Strom Thurmond took to the floor and talked for 24 hours and 18 minutes straight, the longest individual filibuster in Senate history, reportedly dehydrating himself beforehand in a sauna to avoid bathroom breaks. The bill passed a

Year(s): 1957Drama Level: 8.5/10Historical Impact: 7/10Final Vote/Outcome: Civil Rights Act of 1957 ultimately passedFilibuster Involved: ✓Key Figures: Strom Thurmond

added by IJR

The Civil Rights Act of 1964 Filibuster

Southern segregationist Democrats led by Richard Russell filibustered for 60 working days, the longest continuous filibuster in Senate history, until Everett Dirksen delivered enough Republican votes to break it with landmark bipartisan cloture. Hubert Humphrey's tireless floor m

Year(s): 1964Drama Level: 9/10Historical Impact: 9.5/10Final Vote/Outcome: 73-27 (cloture)Filibuster Involved: ✓Key Figures: Richard Russell, Hubert Humphrey, Everett Dirksen

added by IJR

The Joseph McCarthy Censure

After years of reckless Communist-hunting accusations that ruined careers and terrorized colleagues, the Senate finally turned on its own, censuring Joseph McCarthy for conduct 'contrary to senatorial traditions.' Vermont's Ralph Flanders led the charge, breaking the fear that ha

Year(s): 1954Drama Level: 8.5/10Historical Impact: 8/10Final Vote/Outcome: 67-22Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Joseph McCarthy, Ralph Flanders

added by IJR

Clarence Thomas Confirmation & Anita Hill Testimony

Anita Hill's explosive sexual harassment allegations against Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas turned a routine confirmation into a televised national reckoning, with Thomas famously denouncing a 'high-tech lynching.' The all-male Judiciary Committee's handling of Hill's test

Year(s): 1991Drama Level: 9/10Historical Impact: 8.5/10Final Vote/Outcome: 52-48Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Clarence Thomas, Anita Hill

added by IJR

The Bill Clinton Impeachment Trial

Only the second presidential impeachment trial in history put a sitting president's fate over perjury and obstruction charges in the Senate's hands, with Chief Justice William Rehnquist presiding over a chamber deeply split along party lines. Both articles fell well short of conv

Year(s): 1999Drama Level: 8.5/10Historical Impact: 8/10Final Vote/Outcome: Acquitted, 45-55 and 50-50Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Bill Clinton, William Rehnquist

added by IJR

The Robert Bork Confirmation Battle

Senator Ted Kennedy's blistering floor speech warning of 'Robert Bork's America' launched an unprecedented campaign against a Supreme Court nominee, and the Senate ultimately rejected Bork by the widest margin in history for a nominee deemed qualified. The fight was so bitter and

Year(s): 1987Drama Level: 8/10Historical Impact: 8.5/10Final Vote/Outcome: 42-58 (rejected)Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Robert Bork, Joe Biden

added by IJR

The Brett Kavanaugh Confirmation Battle

Christine Blasey Ford's emotional testimony alleging a decades-old sexual assault collided head-on with Kavanaugh's furious, tearful denial, producing one of the most polarizing hearings in modern memory. The FBI's limited follow-up investigation satisfied almost no one, and the

Year(s): 2018Drama Level: 9/10Historical Impact: 7.5/10Final Vote/Outcome: 50-48Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Brett Kavanaugh, Christine Blasey Ford

added by IJR

Harry Reid's 'Nuclear Option' (2013)

Frustrated by years of Republican blockades on executive and judicial nominees, Majority Leader Harry Reid triggered the 'nuclear option,' changing Senate rules by a simple majority to end filibusters on most nominations. Republicans warned darkly it would come back to haunt Demo

Year(s): 2013Drama Level: 7.5/10Historical Impact: 8.5/10Final Vote/Outcome: 52-48Filibuster Involved: ✓Key Figures: Harry Reid, Mitch McConnell

added by IJR

McConnell's Nuclear Option for Supreme Court Picks

After blocking Merrick Garland's nomination for nearly a year, Mitch McConnell extended Reid's nuclear option to Supreme Court nominees to push Neil Gorsuch through over a Democratic filibuster. The move erased the last major use of the filibuster on judicial nominations and pave

Year(s): 2017Drama Level: 7.5/10Historical Impact: 8.5/10Final Vote/Outcome: 52-48 (rule change)Filibuster Involved: ✓Key Figures: Mitch McConnell, Chuck Schumer

added by IJR

John McCain's 'Thumbs Down' on ACA Repeal

In a moment of pure Senate theater, a visibly ailing John McCain — fresh off a brain cancer diagnosis — walked to the well of the chamber and delivered a dramatic thumbs-down, single-handedly sinking the 'skinny repeal' of Obamacare in the middle of the night. Republican leadersh

Year(s): 2017Drama Level: 9/10Historical Impact: 7/10Final Vote/Outcome: 49-51Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: John McCain

added by IJR

Ted Cruz's 21-Hour Anti-Obamacare Speech

Ted Cruz commandeered the Senate floor for over 21 hours, reading Green Eggs and Ham to his daughters via video and delivering a marathon quasi-filibuster against funding the Affordable Care Act, even though it had no procedural power to actually block the bill. The stunt helped

Year(s): 2013Drama Level: 7/10Historical Impact: 5/10Final Vote/Outcome: —Filibuster Involved: ✓Key Figures: Ted Cruz

added by IJR

The Panama Canal Treaty Ratification

President Carter needed a two-thirds majority to hand over control of the Panama Canal, and Majority Whip Robert Byrd engineered a painstaking, senator-by-senator campaign to secure the votes despite fierce conservative backlash back home. Several senators who voted yes later los

Year(s): 1978Drama Level: 6.5/10Historical Impact: 7/10Final Vote/Outcome: 68-32Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: Jimmy Carter, Robert Byrd

added by IJR

The Iraq War Authorization Vote

In the shadow of 9/11, the Senate debated whether to authorize President Bush to invade Iraq, with future presidential rivals Hillary Clinton and John Kerry both voting yes — a decision that would haunt their later campaigns. The overwhelming bipartisan margin masked deep private

Year(s): 2002Drama Level: 6/10Historical Impact: 8/10Final Vote/Outcome: 77-23Filibuster Involved: —Key Figures: George W. Bush, Hillary Clinton, John Kerry

added by IJR