The Hawaiian Islands each offer distinct landscapes, from black sand beaches to lush valleys. Choosing the right one depends on whether you seek adventure, relaxation, or culture. Which island tops your list? Vote now.
What counts: Best is determined by visitor appeal, natural beauty, and accessibility. Only a handful of islands are commonly visited so this list focuses on the major ones with approximate figures.
Maui▲ Rising
Maui rose to the top through its Road to Hana drive and Haleakala sunrise views that deliver both drama and accessibility. The island's mix of beaches and upcountry farms created a signature vacation formula that draws repeat visitors. Its central location made it the natural hub for island hopping.
Area: 727 sq miPopulation: 154,000Annual Visitors: 3,000,000Beaches: 9/10Hiking: 8/10Family Friendly: ✓
added by IJRin 3 rankingsMaui
Hawaii (Big Island)▲ Rising
The Big Island claimed its spot with active volcanoes and the chance to witness lava flows that no other island can match. Vast size allowed it to offer both tropical beaches and alpine terrain in one destination. Its ongoing eruptions keep it in the global spotlight.
Area: 4,028 sq miPopulation: 200,000Annual Visitors: 1,700,000Beaches: 7/10Hiking: 9/10Family Friendly: ✓
added by IJR
Oahu▲ Rising
Oahu secured its place with Waikiki Beach and Pearl Harbor that combine urban energy with historic sites. The island's North Shore waves and hiking trails provide variety within reach of Honolulu's amenities. Its role as the state capital made it the easiest entry point for first-time visitors.
Area: 597 sq miPopulation: 1,000,000Annual Visitors: 5,500,000Beaches: 8/10Hiking: 7/10Family Friendly: ✓
added by IJRin 2 rankingsOahu
Kauai▲ Rising
Kauai earned its high rank with the Na Pali Coast and Waimea Canyon that showcase raw volcanic scenery unmatched elsewhere. The island's small size and strict development rules preserved its jungle character. Its film-famous landscapes continue to attract adventure seekers.
Area: 562 sq miPopulation: 73,000Annual Visitors: 1,200,000Beaches: 8/10Hiking: 9/10Family Friendly: ✓
added by IJRin 2 rankingsKauai
Lanai▲ Rising
Lanai rose through its quiet luxury resorts and the sense of exclusivity that comes from being the smallest inhabited island. Its red-dirt roads and shipwreck beach created an off-the-grid appeal for those seeking seclusion. The island's pineapple plantation history adds a unique story.
Area: 141 sq miPopulation: 3,000Annual Visitors: 150,000Beaches: 7/10Hiking: 6/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRin 2 rankingslanai
Molokai
Molokai earned its ranking with the dramatic Kalaupapa cliffs and a strong Hawaiian cultural presence that feels authentic. Its mule ride and lack of resorts created a destination for travelers wanting to step back in time. The island's rural character remains its strongest draw.
Area: 260 sq miPopulation: 7,000Annual Visitors: 80,000Beaches: 6/10Hiking: 7/10Family Friendly: ✓
added by IJRin 2 rankings
Kahoolawe▲ Rising
Kahoolawe gained attention as the former bombing range turned cultural reserve with restricted access that highlights Hawaiian sovereignty issues. Its barren landscape tells a story of environmental recovery. The island serves more as a symbol than a visitor destination.
Area: 45 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 0Beaches: 3/10Hiking: 4/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRin 2 rankingsKahoolawe
Kaula is a small rocky islet used mainly for military target practice that appears on many island-hopping maps. Its isolation keeps it free of visitors. The islet serves as a navigational marker rather than a destination.
Area: 0.3 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 0Beaches: 1/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRKaula
Necker Island▲ Rising
Necker Island is a small privately managed islet occasionally visited by ultra-high-end guests seeking total seclusion. Its terraced landscape and bird populations create a unique setting. Access is limited to invited visitors only.
Area: 0.1 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 200Beaches: 5/10Hiking: 2/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRNecker Island
Niihau
Niihau stands out as the privately owned island that offers rare helicopter tours and a glimpse into traditional Hawaiian life. Its restricted access created an aura of mystery that appeals to adventure travelers. The island's isolation preserved its unique character.
Area: 70 sq miPopulation: 170Annual Visitors: 5,000Beaches: 8/10Hiking: 5/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRin 2 rankings
Molokini is a crescent-shaped crater that draws snorkelers for its clear waters and abundant fish. Its protected status keeps the reef healthy and the experience consistent. The short boat ride from Maui made it a staple half-day excursion.
Area: 0.1 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 400,000Beaches: 9/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: ✓
added by IJRin 2 rankingsMolokini
Lisianski Island is a small sandy island within the Pearl and Hermes Atoll that supports nesting seabirds and monk seals. Its flat terrain and isolation make it a classic northwestern atoll example. Access is research-only.
Area: 0.5 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 20Beaches: 3/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRLisianski Island
Nihoa is a remote northwestern island with ancient Hawaiian archaeological sites that speak to early settlement. Its sheer cliffs and limited landing spots kept it off most tourist routes. The island is now a protected wildlife refuge.
Area: 0.3 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 100Beaches: 2/10Hiking: 3/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRNihoa
Lehua is a tiny tuff cone off Niihau that offers dramatic sea cliffs and seabird colonies visible from boat tours. Its sheer walls create a striking silhouette against the ocean. The island remains uninhabited and largely untouched.
Area: 0.4 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 10,000Beaches: 4/10Hiking: 2/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRLehua
Laysan Island
Laysan Island is a low-lying atoll island known for its large seabird colony and the rare Laysan duck. Its isolation protected the unique ecosystem from most human impact. Visits are limited to scientific teams.
Area: 1.5 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 30Beaches: 4/10Hiking: 2/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJR
Pearl and Hermes Atoll▼ Falling
Pearl and Hermes Atoll is a remote chain of reefs and islets that once hosted a pearl oyster fishery and now serves as a protected marine area. Its multiple small islands create diverse habitats. Public visits are not permitted.
Area: 0.1 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 10Beaches: 4/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRPearl and Hermes Atoll
Kure Atoll is the northernmost Hawaiian island and the site of a former Coast Guard station now focused on seabird and monk seal protection. Its circular reef and Green Island create a classic atoll. Access is limited to permitted researchers.
Area: 0.3 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 20Beaches: 4/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRKure Atoll
Gardner Pinnacles▼ Falling
Gardner Pinnacles are two towering rock spires that rise dramatically from the ocean and serve as a landmark for the northwestern chain. Their sheer cliffs support limited vegetation and seabirds. No landing is possible.
Area: 0.01 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 0Beaches: 1/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRGardner Pinnacles
Maro Reef is a submerged reef system that appears only at low tide and supports diverse coral and fish populations. Its shallow waters make it hazardous for navigation but rich for marine life. No land exists for visitors.
Area: 0 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 0Beaches: 2/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRMaro Reef
French Frigate Shoals▼ Falling
French Frigate Shoals is an atoll chain famous for green sea turtle nesting and its role in WWII history. The scattered sandbars and lagoon create a rich marine environment. Access is restricted to researchers.
Area: 0.1 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 50Beaches: 6/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRFrench Frigate Shoals
Eastern Island (Midway)
Eastern Island at Midway is a smaller islet used primarily for wildlife research and albatross nesting with fewer facilities than Sand Island. Its quiet beaches and bird colonies provide a more remote feel within the atoll.
Area: 0.6 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 500Beaches: 4/10Hiking: 2/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJR
Midway Atoll▼ Falling
Midway Atoll is best known for its WWII battle and now serves as a national wildlife refuge with limited ecotourism. Its historic buildings and albatross colonies draw a small number of visitors each year. Access requires advance booking.
Area: 2.4 sq miPopulation: 50Annual Visitors: 2,000Beaches: 5/10Hiking: 3/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJRin 2 rankingsMidway Atoll
Spit Island (Midway)▼ Falling
Spit Island is a tiny sand spit at Midway that hosts nesting birds and changes shape with storms. Its ephemeral nature highlights the dynamic atoll environment. Visits are rare and brief.
Area: 0.01 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 100Beaches: 3/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJR
Sand Island (Midway)▼ Falling
Sand Island at Midway is the main hub for the atoll's limited tourism and research operations with historic buildings and a small runway. It serves as the base for albatross viewing and snorkeling trips. Access is controlled.
Area: 1.2 sq miPopulation: 50Annual Visitors: 1,500Beaches: 5/10Hiking: 2/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJR
Disappearing Island (Midway)▼ Falling
Disappearing Island is a low sandbar at Midway that frequently submerges and reappears, illustrating the fragile nature of atoll islands. It offers little more than a resting spot for birds. Access is incidental.
Area: 0.01 sq miPopulation: 0Annual Visitors: 50Beaches: 2/10Hiking: 1/10Family Friendly: —
added by IJR
Free account · your comment posts right after signup
Came for the argument, stayed for the comparison grid. The numbers settle half the fights here.
Missing a few names that belong in the top ten, but the top three is basically right.
Maui at the top is the correct call and I'll die on this hill.