Presidential popularity shapes national identity and policy legacies for generations. Rankings hinge on sustained public regard, cultural resonance, and measurable approval rather than fleeting headlines. Vote to rank these historic figures by overall impact and esteem.
What counts: Best equals highest sustained approval, name recognition, and lasting positive legacy; figures are approximate historical averages from polls and records.
Abraham Lincoln▲ Rising
Lincoln preserved the Union through the Civil War and issued the Emancipation Proclamation, cementing his status as the definitive moral leader. His speeches and assassination elevated him to near-mythic standing in American memory. No other president matches his combination of crisis leadership and enduring reverence.
Peak Approval: 9/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 4Signature Act: Emancipation ProclamationName Recognition: 10/10
added by IJRin 16 rankingsAbraham Lincoln
John F. Kennedy▲ Rising
Kennedy's youthful vigor, Cuban Missile Crisis resolution, and space race vision captured the public imagination during a tense Cold War era. His assassination cut short a promising term and amplified his mythic appeal. Charisma and oratory keep him near the top of popularity lists.
Peak Approval: 8/10Terms Served: 1Years in Office: 3Signature Act: Peace Corps creationName Recognition: 10/10
added by IJRin 11 rankingsJohn F. Kennedy
Ronald Reagan▲ Rising
Reagan restored conservative confidence, ended the Cold War standoff, and delivered memorable optimism after the 1970s malaise. Tax cuts and strong rhetoric defined an era of renewed patriotism. Cultural staying power keeps him near the top of retrospective polls.
Peak Approval: 8/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Tax Reform Act of 1986Name Recognition: 9/10
added by IJRin 16 rankingsRonald Reagan
Barack Obama▲ Rising
Obama's election broke the racial barrier and his Affordable Care Act expanded coverage for millions. Steady handling of the financial crisis and diplomatic openings defined his two terms. Historic firsts and oratory maintain strong modern popularity.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Affordable Care ActName Recognition: 9/10
added by IJRin 17 rankingsBarack Obama
George Washington▲ Rising
Washington set enduring precedents as the first president and voluntarily relinquished power after two terms. His leadership in the Revolution and steady hand during the founding era made him the archetype of republican virtue. Few figures command such universal respect across centuries.
Peak Approval: 9/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Judiciary Act of 1789Name Recognition: 10/10
added by IJRin 10 rankingsGeorge Washington
Theodore Roosevelt▲ Rising
TR broke trusts, created national parks, and projected American power abroad with the Panama Canal. His energetic style and progressive reforms made the presidency a bully pulpit. Conservation and foreign policy boldness sustain his high ranking.
Peak Approval: 8/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Pure Food and Drug ActName Recognition: 9/10
added by IJRin 16 rankingsTheodore Roosevelt
Thomas Jefferson▲ Rising
Jefferson authored the Declaration of Independence and doubled U.S. territory with the Louisiana Purchase. His vision of an agrarian republic and emphasis on liberty shaped national ideals. Enduring intellectual legacy outweighs controversies in public memory.
Peak Approval: 8/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Louisiana PurchaseName Recognition: 9/10
added by IJRin 15 rankingsThomas Jefferson
Franklin D. Roosevelt▲ Rising
FDR guided the nation through the Great Depression and World War II with the New Deal and wartime mobilization. His four-term tenure and fireside chats created an image of reassuring strength. Economic and military victories secured his place among the most admired leaders.
Peak Approval: 9/10Terms Served: 4Years in Office: 12Signature Act: Social Security ActName Recognition: 9/10
added by IJRin 20 rankingsFranklin D. Roosevelt
Harry S. Truman▲ Rising
Truman ended WWII with decisive action, launched the Marshall Plan, and integrated the military. His plain-spoken style and upset 1948 victory endeared him to later generations. Post-presidency honesty boosted his standing dramatically.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Marshall PlanName Recognition: 8/10
added by IJRin 6 rankingsHarry S. Truman
Bill Clinton▲ Rising
Clinton presided over strong economic growth and welfare reform while surviving impeachment. His centrist triangulation and personal charisma kept approval high despite scandals. Economic boom years anchor his retrospective popularity.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Welfare Reform ActName Recognition: 9/10
added by IJRin 16 rankingsBill Clinton
Woodrow Wilson▲ Rising
Wilson led the U.S. into World War I and championed the League of Nations, reshaping global engagement. Progressive domestic reforms and academic background added intellectual weight. League failure and health issues temper but do not erase his influence.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Federal Reserve ActName Recognition: 8/10
added by IJRin 15 rankingsWoodrow Wilson
Adams avoided war with France and established peaceful transfer of power after a bitter election. His legal mind and independence from party extremes earned later respect. Founding-era integrity outweighs one-term brevity.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 1Years in Office: 4Signature Act: Alien and Sedition Acts repeal pushName Recognition: 8/10
added by IJRin 12 rankingsJohn Adams
Johnson passed landmark civil rights and Great Society legislation that reshaped American society. His legislative mastery delivered historic reforms despite Vietnam escalation. Domestic achievements compete with war legacy in popularity assessments.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 6Signature Act: Civil Rights Act of 1964Name Recognition: 8/10
added by IJRin 14 rankingsLyndon B. Johnson
Eisenhower ended the Korean War, built the interstate highway system, and maintained Cold War stability with quiet competence. His farewell warning on the military-industrial complex showed foresight. Post-presidency respect has grown steadily.
Peak Approval: 8/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Federal-Aid Highway ActName Recognition: 8/10
added by IJRin 16 rankingsDwight D. Eisenhower
Jackson expanded presidential power, paid off the national debt, and represented the common man against elites. His military heroism and populist style transformed the office. Indian Removal policies remain a major stain on his legacy.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Indian Removal ActName Recognition: 8/10
added by IJRin 12 rankingsAndrew Jackson
Cleveland won the popular vote three times and restored integrity after Gilded Age scandals. His vetoes of wasteful spending and honest governance earned respect. Two non-consecutive terms highlight his unique appeal.
Peak Approval: 6/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Interstate Commerce ActName Recognition: 7/10
added by IJRin 10 rankingsGrover Cleveland
George Washington (repeat avoided - next is Grant)
Ulysses S. Grant secured Union victory in the Civil War and enforced Reconstruction as president. His military success and later memoirs sustain modern regard despite administration scandals. Battlefield leadership remains his strongest card.
Peak Approval: 6/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: 15th Amendment supportName Recognition: 8/10
added by IJR
William McKinley▼ Falling
McKinley led the U.S. to victory in the Spanish-American War and annexed Hawaii and Puerto Rico. His tariff policies and economic recovery after depression boosted popularity. Assassination cut short a rising star.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 4Signature Act: Gold Standard ActName Recognition: 7/10
added by IJRin 6 rankingsWilliam McKinley
Madison guided the young nation through the War of 1812 and helped craft the Constitution and Bill of Rights. His intellectual contributions to founding documents secure lasting esteem. Early republic survival under his watch adds weight.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 8Signature Act: Bill of RightsName Recognition: 8/10
added by IJRin 9 rankingsJames Madison
Hoover's engineering expertise and WWI relief work preceded a Depression-era presidency marked by economic collapse. Later humanitarian efforts partially rehabilitated his image. Association with the crash caps his popularity.
Peak Approval: 4/10Terms Served: 1Years in Office: 4Signature Act: Smoot-Hawley TariffName Recognition: 7/10
added by IJRin 10 rankingsHerbert Hoover
Carter emphasized human rights and brokered the Camp David Accords while facing energy crises and inflation. Post-presidency humanitarian work has elevated his standing over decades. Honest but beleaguered image defines his arc.
Peak Approval: 5/10Terms Served: 1Years in Office: 4Signature Act: Camp David AccordsName Recognition: 8/10
added by IJRin 11 rankingsJimmy Carter
Gerald Ford
Ford restored trust after Watergate with steady leadership and pardon decisions that cost him politically. His honesty and athletic background humanized the office. Short tenure limited broader impact yet earned quiet respect.
Peak Approval: 6/10Terms Served: 1Years in Office: 2Signature Act: Helsinki AccordsName Recognition: 8/10
added by IJRin 7 rankings
Calvin Coolidge▼ Falling
Coolidge restored calm after Harding scandals with small-government policies and economic growth. His taciturn style and tax cuts defined the Roaring Twenties prosperity. Later nostalgia for limited government sustains moderate popularity.
Peak Approval: 7/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 6Signature Act: Revenue Act of 1924Name Recognition: 7/10
added by IJRin 9 rankingsCalvin Coolidge
Benjamin Harrison▼ Falling
Harrison signed the Sherman Antitrust Act and expanded the navy during a single term. His grandfather's legacy and electoral quirks define limited recognition. Modest accomplishments place him mid-tier in historical memory.
Peak Approval: 6/10Terms Served: 1Years in Office: 4Signature Act: Sherman Antitrust ActName Recognition: 6/10
added by IJRin 6 rankingsBenjamin Harrison
Richard Nixon▼ Falling
Nixon opened relations with China and created the EPA yet resigned in disgrace over Watergate. Foreign policy breakthroughs compete with constitutional crisis in legacy debates. Complex record keeps him polarizing yet discussed.
Peak Approval: 6/10Terms Served: 2Years in Office: 6Signature Act: EPA creationName Recognition: 9/10
added by IJRin 18 rankingsRichard Nixon
William Howard Taft▼ Falling
Taft continued trust-busting and established the postal savings system before becoming Chief Justice. His judicial temperament and later court role add distinction. Split with Roosevelt hurt contemporary standing.
Peak Approval: 6/10Terms Served: 1Years in Office: 4Signature Act: Mann-Elkins ActName Recognition: 7/10
added by IJRin 8 rankingsWilliam Howard Taft
Free account · your comment posts right after signup
This is the most honest version of this ranking I've seen anywhere. The pros and cons are fair.
Missing a few names that belong in the top ten, but the top three is basically right.
Wild that Abraham Lincoln is winning this. Scroll down — the real answer is further down the board.
Somebody explain the Abraham Lincoln votes to me. Genuinely. I want to understand.
Came for the argument, stayed for the comparison grid. The numbers settle half the fights here.